| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. 12:05 - Jul 7 with 6389 views | Snipper |
The standard of refereeing in these Euro’s has been of a very high standard.
Top European referees from Germany, Spain, Italy, Netherlands etc…… seem to be much better than our own Premier League refs.
Do you think it would be beneficial to the Premier League, and other top European leagues, to have European referees officiating in all the top leagues in Europe?
To be honest, I’m sick and tired of refs like Mike Dean thinking the game is about him. I’m not saying let them sod off and ref in Europe, but have a cycle where they do all top leagues. |  | | |  |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 12:09 - Jul 7 with 3121 views | 80s_Boy |
It has been and I'd also add how different the use of VAR has been throughout the tournament compared to in the Premier League.
I'm still very against the us of video technology and will never stop believing that mistakes/oversights happen and people should be used to them by now, but if we are going to use VAR it needs to be as non-intrusive as it has been over the last 3 weeks. |  | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 12:44 - Jul 7 with 3046 views | loftboy |
Completely agree about the referees, not sure how the leagues they ref in now would feel about it though. |  |
| |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 12:51 - Jul 7 with 3042 views | Northernr |
Famous last words, but it's been absolutely superb. Near faultless. Even the VAR hasn't been that obtrusive. Couple of debatable 'modern' reds, and I don't like the change to offside to accomodate the VAR but that's it. I think it's also been noticeable that the poorer refereed games in this league have been the ones done, or VARd, by the Premier League officials.
Thing is, it doesn't seem to be a lot of rocket science, just what a lot of people have been saying for a long time. Relaxed, light touch, don't get involved unless you have to.
- Not every piece of contact is a foul, if we can play on we should. Stop awarding the shtty little stuff and watch the play acting dry up.
- Not every foul is a yellow card. |  | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 13:05 - Jul 7 with 3010 views | LongsufferingR |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 12:51 - Jul 7 by Northernr |
Famous last words, but it's been absolutely superb. Near faultless. Even the VAR hasn't been that obtrusive. Couple of debatable 'modern' reds, and I don't like the change to offside to accomodate the VAR but that's it. I think it's also been noticeable that the poorer refereed games in this league have been the ones done, or VARd, by the Premier League officials.
Thing is, it doesn't seem to be a lot of rocket science, just what a lot of people have been saying for a long time. Relaxed, light touch, don't get involved unless you have to.
- Not every piece of contact is a foul, if we can play on we should. Stop awarding the shtty little stuff and watch the play acting dry up.
- Not every foul is a yellow card. |
yup, can't help thinking that last night when the ball hit Chiellini's hand while he was on the floor, VAR in PL would have called it back for a pen two minutes later having watched it 439 times. Ref didn't give it, play on, no complaints from Spain. |  | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 13:13 - Jul 7 with 2978 views | francisbowles |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 12:51 - Jul 7 by Northernr |
Famous last words, but it's been absolutely superb. Near faultless. Even the VAR hasn't been that obtrusive. Couple of debatable 'modern' reds, and I don't like the change to offside to accomodate the VAR but that's it. I think it's also been noticeable that the poorer refereed games in this league have been the ones done, or VARd, by the Premier League officials.
Thing is, it doesn't seem to be a lot of rocket science, just what a lot of people have been saying for a long time. Relaxed, light touch, don't get involved unless you have to.
- Not every piece of contact is a foul, if we can play on we should. Stop awarding the shtty little stuff and watch the play acting dry up.
- Not every foul is a yellow card. |
Whilst I agree with everything you have said, I do feel this German referee is very slow to get his yellow card out. Italy have got away with a lot. I thought a couple should have been booked in the first half particularly the right back. |  | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 13:16 - Jul 7 with 2972 views | Northernr |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 13:13 - Jul 7 by francisbowles |
Whilst I agree with everything you have said, I do feel this German referee is very slow to get his yellow card out. Italy have got away with a lot. I thought a couple should have been booked in the first half particularly the right back. |
There was a deliberate check on a bloke who'd burst over the halfway line into space on a counter, I thought that was a yellow. But you'd rather it this way right? | | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 13:26 - Jul 7 with 2936 views | rrrspricey |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 13:16 - Jul 7 by Northernr |
There was a deliberate check on a bloke who'd burst over the halfway line into space on a counter, I thought that was a yellow. But you'd rather it this way right? |
I think we all would Clive but players still need to be punished or dirty little fcukers like Phillips will get away with murder (like he has so far this tournament) |  | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 13:34 - Jul 7 with 2924 views | francisbowles |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 13:16 - Jul 7 by Northernr |
There was a deliberate check on a bloke who'd burst over the halfway line into space on a counter, I thought that was a yellow. But you'd rather it this way right? |
I know what you mean but I would rather repeat or cynical offenders got a card early on so that they have to behave for more of the game.
I thought the right back was both of these last night and we had Danny Murphy, who I like, saying nothing wrong with that etc. At one point, after he had committed earlier fouls, he had two hacks in the one incident and still only a free kick was given.
I did like the way this ref played advantage though. Bit like the Aussie we had in the Champ last year. Waited to see if an advantage occurred and called the original foul if it didn't. | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 16:37 - Jul 7 with 2776 views | terryb |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 12:51 - Jul 7 by Northernr |
Famous last words, but it's been absolutely superb. Near faultless. Even the VAR hasn't been that obtrusive. Couple of debatable 'modern' reds, and I don't like the change to offside to accomodate the VAR but that's it. I think it's also been noticeable that the poorer refereed games in this league have been the ones done, or VARd, by the Premier League officials.
Thing is, it doesn't seem to be a lot of rocket science, just what a lot of people have been saying for a long time. Relaxed, light touch, don't get involved unless you have to.
- Not every piece of contact is a foul, if we can play on we should. Stop awarding the shtty little stuff and watch the play acting dry up.
- Not every foul is a yellow card. |
I think that the two English referees improved greatly as the competition went on.
They showed how they could control matches in the Premier IF their bosses allowed them to. This was an eye opener to me as I didn't realise they were as good as they showed. Taylor, after his dreadful start to the Denmark Finland game, looked far better in his next appointment.
The problem in this country is the management of PGMOL & how they appear to believe themselves superior to the rest of the world. Who would have believed that Mike Riley was even worse in management than he was as a referee! | | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 16:39 - Jul 7 with 2771 views | danehoop |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 16:37 - Jul 7 by terryb |
I think that the two English referees improved greatly as the competition went on.
They showed how they could control matches in the Premier IF their bosses allowed them to. This was an eye opener to me as I didn't realise they were as good as they showed. Taylor, after his dreadful start to the Denmark Finland game, looked far better in his next appointment.
The problem in this country is the management of PGMOL & how they appear to believe themselves superior to the rest of the world. Who would have believed that Mike Riley was even worse in management than he was as a referee! |
On your last point, there was no reason to think otherwise.. |  |
| Never knowingly understood |
| |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 16:41 - Jul 7 with 2768 views | PinnerPaul |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 13:05 - Jul 7 by LongsufferingR |
yup, can't help thinking that last night when the ball hit Chiellini's hand while he was on the floor, VAR in PL would have called it back for a pen two minutes later having watched it 439 times. Ref didn't give it, play on, no complaints from Spain. |
Last season yes, this season with new handball law, its not a pen.
Mentioned it before, something that I haven't heard mentioned by any commentator.
There WILL be less handballs in PL and the EFL next season as a result. | | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 16:44 - Jul 7 with 2759 views | PinnerPaul |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 13:16 - Jul 7 by Northernr |
There was a deliberate check on a bloke who'd burst over the halfway line into space on a counter, I thought that was a yellow. But you'd rather it this way right? |
Yep thought he did 'miss' a couple of yellows and hated the fact he NEVER used the advantage signal, so you didn't know if it was advantage or just no foul - but they are minor, niggly criticisms.
As Clive has said re player recruitment and coaching - what do I know, never been near a professional game, let alone an international in my life - but do agree with Clive, this light touch, by both the on field ref and the VAR is so much better than the 'norm'. | | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 16:45 - Jul 7 with 2756 views | Northernr |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 16:41 - Jul 7 by PinnerPaul |
Last season yes, this season with new handball law, its not a pen.
Mentioned it before, something that I haven't heard mentioned by any commentator.
There WILL be less handballs in PL and the EFL next season as a result. |
I did read/hear somebody say nearer the start of the tournament that the reason you were seeing Spanish and Italian players absolutely incredulous at certain handball penalty appeals being waved away is these have been stick on penalties in their domestic leagues for a few years where they've tried the nonsense approach of removing intent or referee discretion and just said if it hits your hand it's a penalty.
I notice Dale Johnson, the ESPN digital guy who basically martyrs himself on social media as the defender of the indefensible when it comes to VAR (if you think it's terrible, he thinks it's wonderful, and vice versa) has been losing his sht at how long it's taking them to show the viewers at home THE LINES in the offside decisions they're making. Nine minutes in one of the group games, apparently, he timed it. Completely missing the point they reached the actual decision in about 20 seconds and the game just carried on with everybody accepting the decision, and then they stuck the diagram up later in a break in play. Personally quite enjoying not spending three minutes after every goal watching somebody draw a line down from somebody's armpit on Microsoft Paint. | | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 16:47 - Jul 7 with 2742 views | nix |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 13:13 - Jul 7 by francisbowles |
Whilst I agree with everything you have said, I do feel this German referee is very slow to get his yellow card out. Italy have got away with a lot. I thought a couple should have been booked in the first half particularly the right back. |
I agree with you Francis, I thought he was too lenient on several blatant rugby tackles with no attempt at all to play the ball by the Italians that should have been yellows in my view. The fact they weren't meant they just kept doing it.
Sometimes free kicks just aren't sufficient punishment as they're obviously more comfortable defending free kicks than being run at.
Having said that I'm glad they ignore the diving and nothing contact that would be fouls in the EPL and EFL. [Post edited 7 Jul 2021 16:48]
|  | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 16:49 - Jul 7 with 2740 views | Northernr |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 16:37 - Jul 7 by terryb |
I think that the two English referees improved greatly as the competition went on.
They showed how they could control matches in the Premier IF their bosses allowed them to. This was an eye opener to me as I didn't realise they were as good as they showed. Taylor, after his dreadful start to the Denmark Finland game, looked far better in his next appointment.
The problem in this country is the management of PGMOL & how they appear to believe themselves superior to the rest of the world. Who would have believed that Mike Riley was even worse in management than he was as a referee! |
TBF I always thought Mike Riley was one of the worst referees we had, consistently, over many, many years, and he's now in charge. Maybe this is an issue. It's the same in rugby league, Steve Ganson was that lethal combination of Mike Dean levels of arrogance and attention seeking with Trevor Kettle levels of incompetence and he's now head of the referees there. | | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 16:49 - Jul 7 with 2739 views | PinnerPaul |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 16:45 - Jul 7 by Northernr |
I did read/hear somebody say nearer the start of the tournament that the reason you were seeing Spanish and Italian players absolutely incredulous at certain handball penalty appeals being waved away is these have been stick on penalties in their domestic leagues for a few years where they've tried the nonsense approach of removing intent or referee discretion and just said if it hits your hand it's a penalty.
I notice Dale Johnson, the ESPN digital guy who basically martyrs himself on social media as the defender of the indefensible when it comes to VAR (if you think it's terrible, he thinks it's wonderful, and vice versa) has been losing his sht at how long it's taking them to show the viewers at home THE LINES in the offside decisions they're making. Nine minutes in one of the group games, apparently, he timed it. Completely missing the point they reached the actual decision in about 20 seconds and the game just carried on with everybody accepting the decision, and then they stuck the diagram up later in a break in play. Personally quite enjoying not spending three minutes after every goal watching somebody draw a line down from somebody's armpit on Microsoft Paint. |
Yep, totally agree.
PGMOL's genius idea next season is "thicker lines"  | | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 16:56 - Jul 7 with 2710 views | Northernr |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 16:49 - Jul 7 by PinnerPaul |
Yep, totally agree.
PGMOL's genius idea next season is "thicker lines" |
Whatever they're doing in this tournament, just do that. Ditch this idea that we know better than Johnny Foreigner, the Premier League application of VAR has been farcical. | | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 17:12 - Jul 7 with 2686 views | LongsufferingR |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 16:49 - Jul 7 by PinnerPaul |
Yep, totally agree.
PGMOL's genius idea next season is "thicker lines" |
Are you sure it wasn't "thicker refs"? | | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 17:37 - Jul 7 with 2634 views | gazza1 |
Refs and Lino's have been good......or is it that we, in this country, have seen some horrid stuff over the past couple of years and our expectations/standards are low. | | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 12:59 - Jul 8 with 2469 views | TheChef |
Of course no sooner was this posted than we had last night one of the worst ref performances of the tournament. |  |
| |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 13:13 - Jul 8 with 2437 views | Stanisgod |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 12:59 - Jul 8 by TheChef |
Of course no sooner was this posted than we had last night one of the worst ref performances of the tournament. |
The worst by far, even the VAR managed to get the two penalty shouts the wrong round. |  |
| It's being so happy that keeps me going. |
| |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 14:45 - Jul 8 with 2333 views | DavieQPR |
I think we got the second because he realised he made a mistake on the first appeal. On the whole the Refs are using VAR to assist them rather than the other way round. |  | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 14:56 - Jul 8 with 2310 views | PinnerPaul |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 12:59 - Jul 8 by TheChef |
Of course no sooner was this posted than we had last night one of the worst ref performances of the tournament. |
What?!!!!
Both could have gone either way - they are subjective decisions, no 'right' or wrong'
Kane's 'penalty' - he did actually kick the Dane's defender's leg first - brilliant spot that I thought.
Sterling actually had 3 contacts, first a trip he recovered from, then a touch on his left ankle and finally a thigh to thigh contact - enough there for a pen for me and certainly not a "clear and obvious error" for VAR to over turn.
DID think that a Dane defender got away with a blatant shirt pull - yellow there I thought and the one of the Danish subs harshly given a yellow for nothing much late on.
Maguire's yellow looked a little harsh at first, but apparently teams were warned pre tournament that these type of challenges would be yellow - so he can't really moan.
Thought the ref had a good game, very calm and , as above, let the game flow when he could. | | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 14:57 - Jul 8 with 2306 views | PinnerPaul |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 14:45 - Jul 8 by DavieQPR |
I think we got the second because he realised he made a mistake on the first appeal. On the whole the Refs are using VAR to assist them rather than the other way round. |
Erm, which is what they are supposed to do - that's what the A in VAR stands for after all! | | | |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 22:14 - Jul 8 with 2204 views | LongsufferingR |
| Great refereeing in the Euro’s. on 14:56 - Jul 8 by PinnerPaul |
What?!!!!
Both could have gone either way - they are subjective decisions, no 'right' or wrong'
Kane's 'penalty' - he did actually kick the Dane's defender's leg first - brilliant spot that I thought.
Sterling actually had 3 contacts, first a trip he recovered from, then a touch on his left ankle and finally a thigh to thigh contact - enough there for a pen for me and certainly not a "clear and obvious error" for VAR to over turn.
DID think that a Dane defender got away with a blatant shirt pull - yellow there I thought and the one of the Danish subs harshly given a yellow for nothing much late on.
Maguire's yellow looked a little harsh at first, but apparently teams were warned pre tournament that these type of challenges would be yellow - so he can't really moan.
Thought the ref had a good game, very calm and , as above, let the game flow when he could. |
Agree with all of that. Supporters of one of the teams involved are probably not always the most objective! | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
