Forum | Another VAR cÃ²ck up... by Swanjaxs

Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... 16:27 - Jan 11 with 1450 views

Penalty overturned for Southampton at Leicester.

VAR is sucking the life out of Premier league football.

	You might think I've forgotten, but one day, when you least expect it, my time will come.
Poll:	Celtic and Rangers should be fast tracked into the Championship ASAP

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 16:30 - Jan 11 with 1440 views

andrew

Was it wrong?

Poll:

Can’t see the new guy coming in to sit on the bench so, who’s off?

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 16:37 - Jan 11 with 1418 views

Swanjaxs

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 16:30 - Jan 11 by andrew
Was it wrong?

Pulled up for offside on the through ball.

Millimeters in it.

The ruling is "clear and obvious error"

Load of bolloxs it is

	You might think I've forgotten, but one day, when you least expect it, my time will come.
Poll:	Celtic and Rangers should be fast tracked into the Championship ASAP

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 16:42 - Jan 11 with 1402 views

Swanjaxs

1-2 Southampton.

Justice.

Southampton have been really impressive to be fair.

Have bossed the game ðŸ‘

	You might think I've forgotten, but one day, when you least expect it, my time will come.
Poll:	Celtic and Rangers should be fast tracked into the Championship ASAP

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 16:42 - Jan 11 with 1395 views

NeathJack

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 16:37 - Jan 11 by Swanjaxs
Pulled up for offside on the through ball. Millimeters in it. The ruling is "clear and obvious error" Load of bolloxs it is

Clear and obvious is not applicable for offside decisions.

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 16:47 - Jan 11 with 1376 views

pembsjack

Should have a time limit of 30 seconds on a review, if they cant decide its a mistake within 30 seconds it means it isnt clear and obvious, so it should stay with the on-field decision. Constantly reviewing decisions over a millimetre isn't football

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 16:49 - Jan 11 with 1370 views

Swanjaxs

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 16:42 - Jan 11 by NeathJack
Clear and obvious is not applicable for offside decisions.

Well it should be.

When they get the ruler out to decide if its offside it becomes a farce!

To be that precise they have to be 100% accurate to when the ball was struck before the incident! Impossible.

Anyways it was onside and they still managed to fÃ¹ck it up.

[Post edited 11 Jan 2020 16:50]

	You might think I've forgotten, but one day, when you least expect it, my time will come.
Poll:	Celtic and Rangers should be fast tracked into the Championship ASAP

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 16:54 - Jan 11 with 1333 views

NeathJack

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 16:49 - Jan 11 by Swanjaxs
Well it should be. When they get the ruler out to decide if its offside it becomes a farce! To be that precise they have to be 100% accurate to when the ball was struck before the incident! Impossible. Anyways it was onside and they still managed to fÃ¹ck it up. [Post edited 11 Jan 2020 16:50]

I agree it should be. The way they are looking at offsides is ridiculous.

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 17:10 - Jan 11 with 1287 views

A_Fans_Dad

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 16:49 - Jan 11 by Swanjaxs
Well it should be. When they get the ruler out to decide if its offside it becomes a farce! To be that precise they have to be 100% accurate to when the ball was struck before the incident! Impossible. Anyways it was onside and they still managed to fÃ¹ck it up. [Post edited 11 Jan 2020 16:50]

Yep, looked on side to me on the VAR.

The Leicester one was way offside and the VAR guy was trying to line it up with the defenders elbow.
At least he eventually got it right.

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 17:19 - Jan 11 with 1257 views

TenbySwan

A lot of disallowed offside goals have been wrong and would gave been considered level before

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 17:28 - Jan 11 with 1233 views

Swanjaxs

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 17:19 - Jan 11 by TenbySwan
A lot of disallowed offside goals have been wrong and would gave been considered level before

Indeed, linesmen make mistakes, and when it's a clear and obvious mistake then more power to var's elbow to step in.

The problem is that var is being used when literally millimetres are involved.

Are they being that precise to when the ball is being struk before the offside ( again we are talking a fraction of a second that could make all the difference when millimetres are being ruled on).

Again, for me the rule needs changing to "clear and obvious"

	You might think I've forgotten, but one day, when you least expect it, my time will come.
Poll:	Celtic and Rangers should be fast tracked into the Championship ASAP

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 18:08 - Jan 11 with 1171 views

Badlands

VAR its it right!

Poll:

Should the summer transfer window close before the season starts?

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 18:39 - Jan 11 with 1144 views

Oldjack

if it's in your favour it's great ,if not tough tits

Prosser the Tosser dwells on Phil's bum hole like a rusty old hemorrhoid ,fact You Greedy Bastards Get Out Of OUR Club!

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 21:37 - Jan 11 with 1027 views

Andy1300

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 16:54 - Jan 11 by NeathJack
I agree it should be. The way they are looking at offsides is ridiculous.

Why don’t they give the ball kicker the same scrutiny?

That could have a massive impact on the outcome

Number 1 team in Wales

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 21:45 - Jan 11 with 1011 views

longlostjack

Message should go into refs earpiece ONLY if there’s a blatant offside or penalty/dive. Otherwise ref should be in control. Cue a smart arse to define blatant.

[Post edited 11 Jan 2020 21:47]

Poll:

Alcohol in the lockdown

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 22:31 - Jan 11 with 961 views

Birchgrovejack

Just get rid of the drawing lines and seeing if the armpit is offside nonsense. We dont need that much accuracy and it takes too long. If he looks level then it's fine.
I dont think it's the VAR idea that's bad, it's the way it's being used.
The hand ball situation is ridiculous too, when the ball is ricocheting onto a hand, when running or amongst bodies in the box etc it shouldn't be hand ball.

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 23:00 - Jan 11 with 934 views

Badlands

If it's level it's off-side.

Poll:

Should the summer transfer window close before the season starts?

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 23:23 - Jan 11 with 917 views

majorraglan

There are issues with VAR and it isn’t perfect, but hopefully it will mean less decisions going against the little guys and an even play field. For too long the big teams had the rib of the green as the smaller teams found to their cost.

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 23:40 - Jan 11 with 905 views

hobo

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 18:39 - Jan 11 by Oldjack
if it's in your favour it's great ,if not tough tits

Wrong, it's awful regardless and needs scrapping

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 07:03 - Jan 12 with 835 views

Phil_S

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 17:28 - Jan 11 by Swanjaxs

Which comes back to the same thing it is not the faulty of VAR it is the people who create the laws of the game that they are asked to follow

West Ham's equalising goal on Friday
Southampton's penalty yesterday

both examples of decisions that I think were wrong but for those in Stockley Park they made the decision that was asked of them

The handball law is a farce and the offside one should allow for clear daylight between attacker and defender and if it isn't there then the on field decision should stand (in a similar way to which you have umpire's call in cricket)

On the flip side you had the decision to send off Abumayeng and a couple of other decisions that were correct over the weekend

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 11:39 - Jan 12 with 758 views

A_Fans_Dad

Another VAR cÃ²ck up... on 23:40 - Jan 11 by hobo
Wrong, it's awful regardless and needs scrapping

Which is exactly what the Ref association want.

Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread