Punching Above Our Weight (2010/11)
Tuesday, 28th Jun 2011 12:00 by Wessex Exile
For many years, a byword for Colchester United – and then Parky took us to the Championship, George for a brief moment even challenged the Premier League play-offs under Robbie and his fortune, and we moved to shiny new WHCS.
Suddenly we seemed to have forgotten that even being in League 1 used to be considered one hell of an achievement, suddenly supporters were expecting, even demanding success, and Robbie had to bankroll that expectation. But not anymore – Robbie has (quite rightly) served notice that his season-on-season bail-out cannot continue – the U’s must learn to stand on its own two feet again, with John Ward’s squad budget limited to the money he can attract through the turnstiles.
Time then to look at the figures, and maybe resurrect the proud tradition that Colchester United is punching above its weight?
The hypothesis for exploring this is simple; attendance equals money, and money equals success – of course there are notable exceptions, former giants with large fan-bases who find themselves languishing in the lower leagues, small clubs with fantastically generous chairmen, and I can’t sensibly factor in revenue from the various cups, transfer money received or televised match revenue – but the general principle is sound.
Accepting that as the 2010/11 season kicked off, there was little any of the 92 could do about the league they found themselves in (regardless of their fan-base), analysis will first look at each of the four leagues independently. As a general note, attendance stats are taken from the excellent website http://www.european-football-statistics.co.uk, and analysis compares rank according to average attendance compared to actual league position, to see who ended up furthest ahead of (or behind) where their attendance average suggested they should have finished in their league (the Punching above Weight rank, or PaW) . Where clubs have matched on their PaW rank, order has been determined by average attendance (smallest to largest).
In the Premier League, the star performer was Fulham, seven places above their attendance rank, followed by West Brom (6 places) and Spurs (5 places). Only Stoke City (13th in the league, 13th in attendance) and Man Utd (1st and 1st obviously) actually finished where they should have done.
The long-suffering Toon Army, with a massive average attendance of nearly 48k will probably not be consoled that they finished nine places below the 3rd position they should have finished in, matched by relegated West Ham, and Wolves five places below the 12th place they should have achieved.
Special mention must go to Bolton and Wigan, both of whom should probably have been relegated on the back of their relatively poor average attendances, but actually managed 14th and 16th place respectively.
Premier League PaW Table
In the Championship, QPR demonstrated perfectly the exception to my rule – on attendance alone they should have been lower mid-table, but bought the league title thanks to the deep pockets of Lakshmi Mittal and friends. Heyho, let’s instead celebrate Swansea’s stunning performance, 15th in the attendance rank, yet promoted via the play-offs, and (begrudgingly) no one’s favourite visitors Millwall, who should have flirted with relegation, and ended up flirting with the play-offs.
Three teams did exactly what it said on the tin; Scunthorpe and PNE were rightly relegated, and Middlesbrough, boring boring Middlesbrough, finished a predictably boring 12th in both ranks.
At the wrong end of business (look away now Mr Happy), with the second largest average attendance in the Championship, Derby should have been promoted, and ended up 17 places down only just avoiding relegation, a feat which Sheff United would probably have paid good money to avoid – 8th highest average attendance and now facing a trip to the WHCS next season. Possibly thanks to the influence of former son of Col U Aidy Boothroyd, Coventry only just avoided a similar fate, seven places below the comfortable mid-table position they should have achieved.
Not much to make special mention about here – Donny did well I suppose to only just avoid relegation, everyone’s favourite Nodge (pfft) should have been disappointed if they hadn’t got promotion, and dirty dirty Leeds, best supported team in the league, must have been gutted to even miss out on the play-offs – shame.
Championship PaW Table
Right then, this is the one that counts – but before we get to the mighty U’s, hat’s off to Rochdale, should have been relegated, but nearly made the play-offs. Colchester United came in a very credible second, our 10th position ten places ahead of the flirting with relegation 20th we should have achieved, and a result matched by Leyton Orient who should have been 17th but nearly made the play-offs in 7th place (though don’t forget their cup-run money).
No one in League 1 did exactly as they should, though Walsall (nearly relegated), Oldham, the Mongs, Huddersfield and Southampton (promoted) finished within one position of their rightful place.
As for the under-performers, Plymuff’s 10pt administration deduction condemned them to relegation when they should have made the play-offs (maybe they should have spent less on golf-balls and throwing away all their loose change), and Swindon and eponymous fallen giants Sheff Wed weren’t too far behind.
Special mention definitely goes to Hartlepool, who should have been relegated but managed to dodge the Mick “Bigger B’stard than…” etc. curse to finish lower mid-table, Brighton for winning the league when they shouldn’t have even made the play-offs, and Parky’s former club Charlton who should have aced the play-offs with 15.5k average support, but only just made top half.
League 1 PaW Table
At the bottom of the tree, clear winner was Accrington Stanley (‘oo are they?); their paltry 1.8k average attendance should have seen them relegated second from last, instead of finishing a whopping 18 places higher in the play-offs. Buckle’s Torquay also did extremely well to finish just inside the play-offs on an average of 2.6k through the turnstiles, and Bury likewise for actually achieving promotion on lower mid-table gates.
At either end of the table, Barnet in 22nd and Shrewsbury in 4th matched expectation with performance, and Crewe, Hereford and Gillingham were only one place off their potential.
The City Gent army will be far from happy that their enormous 11k+ average attendance, comfortably the best in League 1 by a country mile, was rewarded with a season spent trying to avoid relegation out of the league altogether, something that no doubt Stockport 14 places below their average attendance rank wished they avoided when finishing rock bottom of the 92, and even Oxford will feel they should have done a lot better, the 2nd best supported team in the league, but only a mid-table finish.
However, special mention for League 2 is definitely reserved for Macclesfield, officially the worst supported team of the football league, yet still managed a very respectable lower mid-table finish (though do have a chuckle at Sarfend, should have made the play-offs, only just avoided Page 2 on Ceefax).
League 2 PaW Table
Overall ranking for the 92
So finally, looking at all 92 regardless of the league played in, but taking the view that if you cram in tens of thousands every game you really shouldn’t be languishing in the lower leagues (we’re talking about you Sheffield Wednesday), who are the overall winners and losers?
In reverse order:
Bradford City, 47th best supported team and 86th place in the football league (-39!!!);
Our friends Sheff Wed, 29th best supported team and 59th place in the football league (-30);
Oxford, 53rd best supported team and 80th place in the football league (-27);
Derby County, 15th best-supported team (that’s Premier League level!) and 39th place in the football league (-24); and even
Southampton – yes they were promoted out of League 1 in 46th place, but they are actually 25th best-supported team in the league (-21)
Only four teams were exactly where they should have been:
Barnet, virtually bottom of League 2, were 90th in both position and support;
Rotherham and Tranmere were likewise 77th and 62nd respectively in both; and
Everyone’s bête noire ManUre were predictably top of both ranks.
Top of the heap, and worthy recipients of The U’sual Punching above their Weight awards for 2010/11 are:
Accrington Stanley, 2nd from worst supported team in the league, but finished 18 places higher in 73rd (+18);
Colchester United, 73rd in terms of support (that’s mid-table League 2 levels), 54th in position (+19);
Daggers, 85th in support, 65th in position (+20);
Hartlepool, 83rd in support, 60th in position (+23); and finally
Take a bow over-achievers Rochdale, 78th for support (an average of just 3,537 per game), but 53rd place in the football league (+25).
The 92 PaW Table
Photo: Action Images
Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.
You need to login in order to post your comments
Blogs 31 bloggers
Letters from Wiltshire #44 by wessex_exile
So here we are, as the nation mourns the passing of His Royal Highness, Duke of Edinburgh, the U’s face the first of two season-defining moments, with our late kick-off match at home to Walsall. Before then, no doubt many will have been focused on events elsewhere, not least the early kick-offs for Grimsby (at home to promotion-chasing Bolton Wanderers), and particularly Essex rivals Southend United, who faced a tricky visit to Exeter City – still very much in the hunt for at least a play-off spot. As I finalise this blog, I know that Grimsby have beaten Bolton 2-1, and Southend earned a credible 0-0 draw in the West Country. More to the point, the U’s will know this too. Whilst I can’t help but feel that will ought to be to our advantage, it surely must also put additional pressure on a squad whose confidence is paper-thin. We must hope that Hayden Mullins, assisted by Paul Tisdale, get their heads right, and send the lads out this evening fired up with self-belief.
Letters from Wiltshire #43 by wessex_exile
Well, that has been a lively week for Colchester United in the press, and not least for Robbie Cowling, with not one, or two, but kind of three club announcements in rapid succession to try and put the record straight. First, we had Tribunalgate, which certainly looked very poor according to the initial press reports, but which on closer inspection when some of the ‘fact gaps’ were filled in wasn’t anywhere near the story that some would have us believe. Then of course we had the ‘leak’ that the U’s were about to go into administration, despite all the reassurances we’d been given in previous statements from Robbie. Not so said Robbie again, and particularly angry at what he believed to be the source of the story. Hence statement #3, repeating his assurances, but this time after passing through the lawyer filter to remove his thoughts on the source. To paraphrase Robbie’s conclusion to that statement, let’s hope we can all have a day off from this sort of media shenanigans and enjoy our game at Oldham tonight!
Letters from Wiltshire #42 by wessex_exile
Well, these sure are strange times at Colchester United, particularly for a club (nor a Chairman) not usually associated with the ‘managerial revolving door’ approach. With results not matching expectations or even minimum requirements, and a brief spell after being appointed Interim Head Coach, Wayne Brown has been released to return to the Jammers, for whenever their pandemic-interrupted football restarts. In comes not one, or two, but three new ‘appointments’. Hayden Mullins steps up as Head Coach to the end of the season, Joe Dunne apparently comes back to the U’s in a sort of unofficial coaching/ team-spirit sort of role, and exceptionally experienced lower-league former Exeter City manager Paul Tisdale arrives to provide Hayden with advice and support – crikey!
Letters from Wiltshire #41 by wessex_exile
This afternoon the U’s take on Bradford City in a bid to gather sufficient points to stay clear of the bottom two. It’ll be a tough gig though, even if (as I suspect) Bradford City have left it a bit too late to challenge the play-off spots. They were on a decent run of form, that is until defeats at Newport, Carlisle, Scunthorpe and a goalless draw at home to Oldham put paid to any lingering promotion hopes. For us, it’s simple, to stay out of the bottom two, for all intents and purposes we only need to gain half (or more) of the points that Grimsby or Southend do. Sounds easy, just wish I felt more confident we will…
Letters from Wiltshire #40 by wessex_exile
Today we learned the sad news that Peter Lorimer has passed away, aged 74, after a long-term illness. Love or loathe Revie’s Leeds, no one can deny that “Hotshot Lorimer” was a truly magnificent footballer, and his passing is a sad day for the global football family.
Leeds United Polls
[ Vote here ]