Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Saints V West Brom The Preview
Saints V West Brom The Preview
Monday, 5th Nov 2012 11:07

Make no mistake about it, this game could be pivotal in whether we stay up or go down come the end of the season.

Some will say its a bit dramatic to make such a sweeping statement about what on the face of it is a run of the mill game for West Brom themselves, but the stark reality of our situation is that by the end of November, we will either be just about keeping our heads above water at the best, and at the worst we will be completely cast adrift from safety.

There are some big words being spoken by both the manager and various squad members, but the time for big words is now over, the time for excuses is over, the time for big actions is now.

Firstly Nigel Adkins has to show us that he is the man for the job, we all know that he is working under difficult conditions and we all know that he did not get the players that he wanted in the transfer window, we all suspect that he is perhaps being forced to play a formation that he knows he hasnt the personel to play, but the fact is we still have a half decent squad and we could have and indeed should be getting a lot more from it than we are, the manager now needs to show that he can select the right team and put right some of the errors of previous games.

If Nigel can do that then he can retain the respect of the squad and with that we have a base to build on and get back the confidence that we are lacking, we go out there expecting to concede and that leads to panic and mistakes at the back.

The manager has to address the key areas, the goalkeeping position is still uncertain and at time of writing it could be any one of our three keepers selected for duty tonight and that tells you something and that something isnt very positive, having dont that he needs to recognise that the problems are not being caused down the flanks by the full backs alone, but by the lack of cover for them, deal with these areas and we have a foundation to build on, fail to deal with them and use the likes of Lallana, Guly and even Puncheon out wide and we will be in trouble, as we have been in virtually every other game this season,  say this phrase a lot, but "do the same things and you get the same results" we are away from home lets build from the back.

Personally I would restore Gazzaniga to the goal, to be blunt he looked OK in the games he played, not brilliant but OK and Ok is better than what either Davis or Boruc have given us so far.

The back four almost picks itself, Clyne,Fonte Yoshida and Fox are the best we have, Fox has come in for a lot of stick, but when he hasnt been playing the problems in that position have been just as bad if not worse, as i say the problem isnt entirely the left back position, its the cover provided which is non existent.

Midfield is crucial, especially the two wide players, I would play Reeves wide on the left, Chaplow wide on the right, these are perhaps the best players to shore up our flanks we have available, in the centre chneiderlin and Steve Davis to anchor the centre and Adam Lallana playing in the hole in front of them.

Up front its a difficult choice and i know my view on this isnt going to be the popular one, but I would play Jay Rodriguez up front, away from home he suits this role better than Lambert, in that he has more mobility and as at Man City on the opening day, bringing on Lambert in the final stages might be a good option.

This would leave a fairly strong bench, including Lambert, Mayuka, Ward Prowse, possibly Ramirez, add a sub keeper and Hooiveld and you have a good balance available to bring on in any situation whether we are chasing the game or looking to close it out.

Good sides build good foundations to start with and having done that they get stronger as the game goes on and impose themselves, West Brom are no pushovers, they have won four and lost one of their five home games played so far, they are a solid side at home, but they are not a great side overall and are beatable, but we have to get it right defensively first and then build on it, the longer we can keep a clean sheet then hopefully the stronger we can get.

Nigel Adkins has a thankless task at the moment, how thankless we may never know, but good managers come good in these positions, we now need to find out that Nigel can see what is wrong with the side and rectify it, at the end of the day he may be getting instructions from elsewhere, but he is the man handing the teamsheet in, he ultimately has the last say, time to go down playing the players that you want to play rather than as you are alledgedly being told, sadly if this is his own choice then I worry if he is the man for the job, even more worryingly though, if this isnt the managers choice, then the problems could get far far worse.

Photo: Action Images via Reuters



Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.



brady100 added 12:34 - Nov 5
IMO I think Ramirez has to start providing he can play at least 60-70 mins. We have desperately missed his creativity. Stick with Boruc in goal, I agree there is a strong case for both Gazzaniga and Davis but I don't think it sends out a good message to change again.
0

stmichael added 13:07 - Nov 5
Play Fox and drop Lambert mmmmm!!
In your own words "do the same thing get the same results".
You dont need mobility when you play 1 up you need somebody to HOLD the ball up.
Not only is SRL the best in the club at doing this he is one of the best in the country.
Add to this he is our best finisher , our goal scorer , our penalty taker , our heart beat - do i need to go on?
FOX has got off the hook this season for his performances because people have been brain washed into thinking its the fault of the midfielders.
Yes that is an issue but his individual howlers are down to him and there are too many of them.
He has to be in last chance saloon tonight in my opinion.
0

tiptop added 13:08 - Nov 5
Agree Nic.
(Can't believe NA will be told to play a system that isn't working and he might not want to use. It seems, ne, it is madness).

We've needed to set out a more solid stall for a while but the same attacking ambitions/principles persist.
Surely no further evidence is needed to prove we NEED to change?!
West Brom like to play on the break from what I have read and starting in an attacking mode as we were at the start at Everton will just play straight into Steve Clarke's hands. Surley we wont?
Gazzinga in goal.
We need to be tight, tenacious and keep it simple to give ourselves A CHANCE of competing with WB's quality and belief that could over-run our (diminishing) confident enthusiasm.
Essentially not doing this amounts to running before we can walk in this league.

I understand the decision to get a more mobile player to chase down the defence from the KO. Jayrod looked good after his goal last week and he needs/we need his confidence to grow and start playing like he can. When he is on his game and playing with confidence it will be like a new signing..

Reeves has been banging the door and looks a safe bet to me. He would have been in earlier for me too. Agree with Chappers too.
Bench is looking healthier tho.
Davis, Ramirez, Lee, Mayuka, Lambert, Ward-Prowse, Hooiveld
0

ItchenNorth added 13:29 - Nov 5
I'd like to see us back to a 442

Boruc
Reeves, Yoshi, Fonte, Clyne
Lallana Schneiderlin, Chaplow, Ramirez
Mayuka, Lambert

As much as Ramirez is clearly the most talented player we have, I'd put him out wide with Chaplow box to box and Schneiderlin holding.
Its still very attacking, but hey if you can't keep em out, go get them yourselves esp against West Brom.

Steven Davis must be dropped imo.
0

SaintNick added 13:45 - Nov 5
Mike, no one is being brainwashed that the problem for the full backs is the lack of midfield coverage, its fact.

Whoever has been played at left back has had the same problem and been ripped apart be it Fox, Clyne, Yoshida or Shaw, so thats four left backs in the space of 12 games, all have been shredded, Im not saying any of them are great, only what i have been saying for ages, you could play Ashley Cole there at present and he would be ripped apart because of no cover, Fox has been on the pitch for 17 of our 30 goals conceded, so he is getting slaughtered for being the most at fault, yet hasnt been on the pitch for almost half the goals conceded, things have got no better when he hasnt been there
0

simmo400 added 15:55 - Nov 5
Our defence has been a shambles for a year not just this season. Only Blackpool and Reading last season exploited it. We should have learnt from the last dozen games of last season when we were all over the place. We need to stay in the game tonight as long as we can. No soft goals...clear our lines etc. Once we go behind we are finished.
0

REEDYREEDOREEDZ added 16:33 - Nov 5
I think we all know that Saints are gonna go there and 'try to impose ourselves and control the football' as Nigel likes to say. Saints aren't going to sit back and make themselves hard to beat, they're gonna have a go. So this will prob leave us wide open to the likes of Odemwinge on the counter-attack and there will inevitably be plenty of goals again.
It all comes down to our defence and midfield really. If they can cut out the silly errors, not give away any cheap goals, provide cover for the full-backs and win the individual battles against the likes of Lukaku then we have a good chance of getting a result, because I think we will always score goals, especially if Ramirez is fit again.
We really need at least a point tonight to get ourselves off of the bottom. West Brom have been excellent at home this season so to go there and get a point will be a very good result. I just struggle to see how its going to happen though....
0

slynch added 17:24 - Nov 5
St Nick, all the LBs that have replaced Fox are somewhere from 2nd rate to rubbish, Reeves, Shaw, Yosh, Clyne, you can decide which one's which. But don't panic, I've got the solution.

Backline
Clyne, Fonte, Yosh Hooi, Fox,

When attacking Clyne, Yosh Fox come out into MF

MF
Ram/Punch Davis Gully/Lallana

The "/ " is there for injury and tiredness. The Two wingers push back in defence and push up in attack.

Front

Mayuka Lamb

GAZZA in goal

5/3/2 Let's hope Adkins is reading this
0


You need to login in order to post your comments

Blogs 31 bloggers

Leeds United Polls

About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2026